Skip to main content

Once a shining star in the Boston charter school world, City top top a Hill is encountering a enormous financial crisis, prompting trustees on Monday to enact a series of dramatic spending plan cuts: lock will soon lay off 23 teachers, administrators, and other staffers at their new Bedford school and two Roxbury schools and will near the brand-new Bedford campus in June.

You are watching: City on a hill new bedford

The plan, announced ~ a trustees meeting Monday morning, immediately sparked outrage. In Roxbury, parental of one college quickly started to organize in opposition come one aspect of the budget plan cuts: merging your school, located on Circuit Street, with an additional in Dudley Square as soon as January.


The big concerns because that the parents: crime, public drinking, and drug use in the Dudley Square neighborhood and also a failure of college officials come consult parents. Family members were at the college Friday night because that a Thanksgiving potluck, and school officials never pointed out the budget plan cuts or the Monday board meeting, parents said.

“It totally floored me,” claimed Dalles Smith, whose boy attends the Circuit Street school. “I don’t want my boy to have any part of Dudley Square.”

The sweeping budget cuts stand for the recent turbulent turn for the nearly 25-year-old charter school, which has been struggling with management turnover, lackluster academic performance, and financial woes. Earlier this year, state officials put the brand-new Bedford campus ~ above probation, and also a year previously teachers at all three sites unionized, a rarity for independent charter schools, which ar a premium on operational autonomy.

The severity the this fall’s financial situation emerged after head counts at the three campuses revealed enrollment had dropped because that a 2nd year in a row. That, in turn, will result in a loss of thousands of thousands the dollars in per-student aid from the state and also federal governments. The 3 campuses run as independent schools overseen by a single board of trustees and also an executive, management team.


“This is a really difficult decision, and also we don’t take it lightly,” stated Cara Stillings-Candal, chair of the trustees in an interview after the board meeting. “We wouldn’t have made this decisions if it wasn’t in the best interest the families and students.”

Just 570 college student are at this time enrolled in grades 9 through 12 throughout City on a Hill’s three campuses, leave 270 seat empty. The Boston campuses receive about $20,000 per college student in state help and the brand-new Bedford site gets around $15,000 every student. Last year’s enrollment drop led to an $842,000 lose in state and also federal aid.

The consolidation of the Boston schools would allow for under administrators and also teachers. Currently, each structure operates as a separate high school, resulting in smaller 보다 ideal class sizes, college officials said. Under the consolidation, every ninth- and also 10th-graders will attend classes at the Circuit Street location and also all 11th- and 12th-graders will go to Dudley Square.

Some parents room worried the larger class sizes could reason their kids to flounder, if teachers, that are represented by the Boston teacher Union, hoped layoffs will be minimal.

“At this point, we have numerous concerns around the current plans,” Sam Hughes, a dean at the Dudley Square school and also a member the the bargaining committee, stated in a statement. “Teachers and also staff room eager to work with the trustees to alleviate the negative impact the planned cut will have — and also to comment on with them how to bring much-needed stability to our schools and for our students’ education and learning moving forward.”


The consolidation will require state approval because each campus is administer by their own operating patent granted by the state education board.

School officials defended the plan.

“Our priorities are, an initial and foremost, student academic outcomes and also preserving as numerous teaching positions together possible,” stated Kevin Taylor, the school’s chef executive, in a statement. “As such, we will prioritize eliminating non-teaching and other bureaucratic roles.”

In announcing the budget plan cuts, City top top a Hill officials suggested that the difficulties in new Bedford were so major that that was most likely they would certainly fail to turn the institution around. The recent MCAS scores, exit in September, were amongst the lowest in the state and worse than those because that the new Bedford institution system: simply 16 percent the 10th-graders met or gone beyond expectations in English exams and also only 14 percent did in math.

“As a Board, we think that relinquishing the charter now, quite than awaiting most likely closure by later on in the year, is the just viable and responsible next step,” Stillings-Candal said in a statement.

New Bedford Superintendent cutting board Anderson stated he will job-related with City on a Hill to make certain students have actually a smooth shift into the institution system.

“We space willing to do what is essential to assist in this situation,” Anderson claimed in a statement. “New Bedford public Schools always was and also continues to it is in the best education alternative for these students.”


City top top a Hill’s closure will carry a financial benefit to the city of brand-new Bedford. ~ this school year, that no much longer will have actually to offer up numerous thousands of dollars in state education aid to covering tuition costs. In a statement, market Jon Mitchell of brand-new Bedford claimed he to be pleased that financial responsibility would end.

“I am grateful that Commissioner Riley has actually moved to end the work of a school whose record of low accomplishment and high attrition was specifically what numerous of us predicted when it was an initial proposed,” Mitchell said.

A state education spokeswoman claimed the commissioner had actually not made any kind of formal decision about the brand-new Bedford campus before the trustee vote Monday. The state had provided the brand-new Bedford site until December 2020 to present a significant and sustained development in its academic performance.

City ~ above a Hill was among the first group of charter institutions to open up in Massachusetts in 1995, setup up its first campus inside a YMCA beside Northeastern University. It cultivated a knack for enrolling students that were behind academically and preparing them for this reason they could be successful in college. State education officials deemed the school a “proven-provider” previously this decade, paving its way to open a second school in Boston in 2013 and also another in brand-new Bedford in 2014.

State education officials this year designated the Circuit Street college as requiring assistance and also intervention because of a low high school graduation price — 54 percent in 2018 according to the most recent state data. MCAS scores, released in September, were also well below the state and Boston institution district averages, v 26 percent the students meeting or exceeding expectation in English and also 24 percent in math.


The Dudley Square location had also lower MCAS scores: 16 percent of students met or gone beyond expectations in English and also 20 percent did in math. But it had actually a greater graduation rate, 70 percent.

Paul Reville, a previous state education secretary, stated City on a Hill’s troubles with its development highlights the require for state officials to much more closely scrutinize charter schools that want to expand.

“Scaling up any kind of organization is a challenge,” stated Reville, who referred to as City top top a Hill’s outcomes disappointing.

See more: Lost Sector Guide: Bay Of Drowned Wishes Lost Sector, Bay Of Drowned Wishes

James Vaznis can be got to at james.vaznis
globe.com. Monitor him on Twitter