People in love — on behalf of English majors and also book lovers everywhere — please stop using this Wuthering Heights quote to explain the depth of her passion and romance:

Whatever ours souls are made of, his and also mine are the same.

You are watching: Whatever souls are made of his and mine are the same

Here are four reasons this quote, in addition to Heathcliff and also Catherine’s relationship, is no romantic:

One // Incest

Heathcliff and also Catherine are an extremely likely half siblings.

Even if you nothing believe/agree v the — albeit little — evidence that they space biologically related, lock were raised together as brother and also sister.

In the 1800s, regulations prohibited adopted children, foster children, or any type of children elevated together native marrying one another, and Brontë’s 19th century readers would know that. V the eyes of the law, Heathcliff and also Catherine to be siblings.

Either means — organic or societal — that pretty incestuous.

Two // Codependent

Color Heathcliff and also Catherine codependent.

They both desire to be each other. Catherine says, “He’s much more myself than I am.” at one point, she states she is Heathcliff. ~ Catherine’s death, Heathcliff literally and desperately wants his body to be joined v hers, so they can decompose together. That is no romantic, and also it is no sexual. It is, however, unhealthy codependence.

If every else perished, and also he remained, I need to still continue to be; and if every else remained, and he were annihilated, the world would revolve to a mighty stranger.

See: codependency.

Three // Toxic

Not only was their relationship codependent, it to be violent, toxic, and obsessive. In part respects, they also idolize one another.

Catherine threatens to haunt Heathcliff and drive him their common doom, and also determined to specific revenge top top his regarded injustice, Heathcliff ruins everyone’s life around him (including Catherine’s own daughter).

Spurned through jealousy and also fits of rage, this two have actually a classically and dangerously toxicity connection. Lock don’t desire each other, however they don’t want anyone else to have them either. Maybe it’s born the end of their isolation, loneliness, and/or social ambition, however whatever the reason, their is a devastating relationship.

Four // Platonic

Despite their damaging toxicity, Catherine and also Heathcliff are spirit mates. Castle belong together however not together lovers. It’s an idolized, obsessive connection. As this Bustle article explains:

They effort to transcend the borders of human being subjectivity and physicality — to come to be something the is other and also only them. Their partnership in the novel is strange and fascinating, but it’s no love.

There is zero indication that Catherine or Heathcliff have actually romantic, sex-related chemistry. They no physically attractive to one an additional like Catherine is come Edgar Linton (the man she marries), and also since she is pregnant and also dies after providing birth, we, as readers, recognize Catherine has had sex.

In fact, if you analysis this story from a historical lens (which is important since mores, morals, and day-to-day living to be different), a modern-day audience might far better understand that Victorian-era audiences thought about the “opposites attract” preeminence to it is in the summary of romantic love.

… because he’s an ext myself 보다 I am. Everything our souls are made of, his and also mine space the same, and is as various as a moonbeam native lightning, or frost from fire.

Heathcliff and Catherine are the same; therefore, their is a platonic love, if Catherine and also Linton room opposites and therefore more symbolic the Victorian-era romantic love.

Catherine says:

I am Heathcliff. He’s always, constantly in mine mind: not as a pleasure, any an ext than ns am constantly a satisfied to myself, however as my very own being.

And that, straight from the horse’s mouth, carries the load of the point: this is no a romance. Catherine and Heathcliff, though linked by your souls, have actually an eerily incestuous, deep codependent, dangerously toxic, and (at times) hostilely platonic relationship.

See more: Cultural Anthropology: Asking Questions About Cultural Anthropology Pdf

The only reason we think about Wuthering Heights a romantic is because of moody movie adaptations and also bad high institution English teachers. So, i plead through you all, the betrothed, married, and stupid-in-love couples the the world, please protect against using this quote to describe your relationship.